AADA sets the record straight on access to repair info debate: Part Three
In the third and final part of the Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) series of articles, chairman, Ian Field, explains why why dealerships are not the enemy as has been pointed out in the media and also why he believes the information and opinions put out by the Australian Automotive Aftermarket Association (AAAA) and the Australian Automobile Association (AAA) are disingenuous and meant to protect a large number of its key members, which include national retail service and repair chains, Repco and Autobarn.
According to Field, “the AAAA are being disingenuous and are predominantly looking to protect their extensive list of parts manufacturers who form part of their board and member group, members like Repco and Autobarn want access to all the relevant data that could allow them to reverse engineer what the OEMs have to pay a lot of money to create.”
“Independent repairers can remain in the industry by specialising in certain brands or what style of repair they want to specialise in,” he says.
The issue according to Field is that “some non-dealer franchisee organisations like Repco and Autobarn have created the expectation amongst the public that they can do anything a dealership can do, well they can’t, unless they buy all the specialist tools and information that the dealers buy for each and every one of the brands.”
“When you have 65 brands and over 300 current models the cost to be up to date on all brands and the model derivatives is just not economic. They also want to be given the current technical service bulletins to be as up to date as the dealerships.
“It’s disingenuous to suggest that every make and model in Australia can be fixed at a Repco or at an Autobarn, they just can’t. Nondealers can do basic repairs and service on main stream brands like Ford, Holden, Toyota, Mitsubishi, or Nissan when they invest in the equipment, training and information, to do that.
As Field puts it,”changing the oil and filters is not the same thing as a full dealer service. I don’t think buying the equipment and information to service a non-main stream brand would be economic, unless you specialise.”
“Maybe that’s why AAAA, pushes the unrealistic expectation with small independent repairers it should be free, or that dealerships should lend their equipment. What they want in my view is to make sure that the prices they pay are as cheap as possible, nothing wrong with that but they say it’s not available. And that’s just NOT TRUE.”
“OEM’s aren’t willing to give away their trade secrets because it’s unique to their brand and gives them a commercial advantage for a limited time. I’m sure Repco and Autobarn would love to get their hands on some of this information, but OEM’s won’t give them that info and nor will they give it to dealerships.”
“You don’t need that sort of information to repair and service, only if you want to make alternative parts.”
“It is not a fair argument from the AAAA to say they are looking after independent repairers when the independent repairers are in the State and Territory MTA organisation like MTAQ and VACC and not theirs. They represent predominately parts manufacturers and importers a different part of the industry,” he adds.
The AAA are saying their roadside assistance members want access to info to fix broken down cars. But Field comments: “If you arrive to fix a SAAB for example and try and access the EMS you won’t be able because you won’t have the right scan equipment. What they can do is a tyre change, or put petrol in the car or open a door or start a flat battery, but you can’t re-immobilise the EMS unless you have the right equipment. You certainly can’t make the car drivable without linking to the appropriate test equipment and information.
“If the AAA is arguing they should be able to do that on the road side, with direct access to all the info from the OEM, this, would mean that the whole world would have to agree to use the same codes, access boards, and equipment and that’s just not going to happen.”
“The AAAA and the AAA are being disingenuous; they are not telling the story the way it is. All the repair and service information is available, from many information providers and VACC claim they can provide 98% from one source. There are legitimate security and propriety reason some info isn’t available.
“The debate should be what the price is and how hard is it to get,” Field notes.
Dealerships not the enemy
According to Field reports in the media suggesting that new car dealerships will block independent mechanics from accessing information, tools and computer programs needed to repair new vehicles are inaccurate and paint dealerships as the enemy.
He notes: “Dealerships are not the enemy as they have no reason to withhold information from independents repairers.”
“There is an assumption that the dealers don’t share this info with their customers, giving the impression that we are the enemy. We sell parts to panel beaters and independent repairers, and if they ring us and ask us for the information we give it to them, we don’t hide this information, if we did keep info from them they wouldn’t be customers in the first place,” Field says.
He points out that there are five times more independent repairers than car dealers in Australia.
“So they must be doing their job or else there would be a lot of broken down cars on the side of the road, where is the market failure?”
In an AADA press release, chief executive Patrick Tessier said the organisation was confident independent repairers who genuinely wanted to own vehicle repair information had complete access to the information needed to service and repair any vehicle on Australian roads.
“The simple fact is that information is available at a reasonable cost for all parties, independent or dealer, through a number of different delivery methods,” he says.
“If it isn’t available then the independent repairers are totally misleading the public into believing they can service and repair cars, which is clearly not the case.”
Tessier also points out that dealers also traded vehicles outside the franchise brand they sell and then had to buy the service and repair information just like independent repairers.
“No service or repair information is withheld at all,” he adds.
Service repair manuals are sold through dealership parts departments and have been for many years.
“Comments from some who don’t service cars and others who think the information should be free are not living (in) the commercial environment that AADA members and most business people operate in,” Tessier concludes.
Tho read Part One and Part Two of the series of AADA articles, please click here for Part One and here for Part Two.
Join the conversation