AADA sets the record straight on access to repair info debate: Part Two
The real issue is access to EMS codes not lack of repair info: Field
Field comments that 52 years ago when he started in the industry repair shops were all the same, you could get any car fixed with just a screwdriver and some wire.
He notes, “Today, unless you have got the appropriate piece of test equipment to plug in, which then you need to be able to interpret the access codes that you are given, you can’t do anything.”
“Cars don’t break down like they used to. They go into limp home mode and you can’t switch off the limp home codes on the dashboard unless you have the right equipment. Therein lies the issue with many of the independents. They [the independent repairer] want to be able to switch off their warning signals, without necessarily investing in all the training, equipment and buy the parts to fix it and that’s not something the OEMs are going to allow or appropriate if we are serious about safety systems and emission control settings.
He notes that even dealerships don’t have access to these codes: “There is no reason for the dealerships to have access to this information, the factories don’t want anyone tinkering with emissions settings or fuel mixture settings, they want those settings to be locked in place by the EMS.”
“Now the debate is around why aftermarket people – who represent the aftermarket parts manufacturers – say they have every right to have as much information to do their job, but let’s not pretend it’s about a lack of repair information, it’s got everything to do with the EMS codes and the algorithms that they need for the central brain of the car to recognise a non-genuine part that’s been fitted to the car. This is what the real issue is about; Field says.
He notes that at the last meeting held just over a month ago all the parties involved seemed happy with what the FCAI had put on the table. According to Field, “AAAA didn’t like the position that customers should be informed when nongenuine parts were fitted. FCAI and AADA s position is the customer should make an informed decision, not just assume they are the same as dealers fit.”
“The process agreed on was that each of the five parties involved would put out their own document and we would attempt to find an overriding principal document that essentially states that the information will be made available at commercially reasonable prices.
“How much more do you need to give them?” asks Field.
Field also notes that VACC wrote to all the Motor Trade Authorities (MTA) to make their VACC library of vehicle repair information available at a small cost, so anybody could get access to the information, including three months free access.
“Of the close to 1000 independent repairers in Queensland, 27 took up the offer, if there is this massive problem and only 27 took up the offer, how big a problem is it really? Field also asks.
The online information portal known as, Tech Online, provides subscribers with access to over 55,000 pages of technical information covering 9000 vehicle models and variants. For those that cannot find the information online they can choose to subscribe to VACC’s telephone-based library where a technical advisor can help them find the right info.
There are three packages available – Standard, Gold and Platinum – $720 per year plus $8 per technical call (Standard), $960 per year plus $8 per technical advisory call above 12 calls per year (Gold), and $1200 per year with unlimited technical calls (Platinum).
To find out more and to register for Tech Online email your contact and business details to admin@tech-online.com.au or call (03) 9829 1152.
All the right info for the right price
According to Field, every vehicle that gets produced comes with workshop manuals, the problem is that they are not cheap and there are just too many models in Australia.
As Field puts it, “you could be AHG or AP Eagers and you still wouldn’t buy every one of these manuals, so what independents want is access to an internet-based system and therein is the issue.”
The FCAI has noted it would create a website where people can register and pay a monthly fee to access the information that is available.
“I don’t think it is unreasonable to have unlimited access to this information, it shouldn’t cause independent repairers a problem, however he does note that “if you are only going to service one car from a particular model a year, maybe that is too much, but then how do you get around that?”. Without the scanning equipment having the information, is of no value. Without the technical training required of dealer mechanics, the information is useless.”
Field notes that at the end of the day the old corner mechanic will become a dying breed, not because they are not smart enough, but because the cost to acquire the equipment, training and information to service every make and model is just prohibitive.
“We are not talking about, filter and oil changes or brakes and suspension and clutches. We are talking about the EMS algorithms that you can’t get access to unless you have the right test equipment, which is very expensive, and multi-scan systems do not cater for all makes and models.”
Field also points out that Toyota have not ‘broken ranks’ as suggested by media reports have put out, what has happened is that they are making product recall information to independents. “But why would independents want to handle recalls unless they are getting paid by the OEM to do the work, manufacturers pay the dealer body to do the work on a recall,” Field argues.
“Toyota already tells the general public about recalls, Is this article suggesting that Toyota is going to let independent repairers do the rectification work, I can assure you that’s not what they said.”
Part three in this series of three AADA articles will be available on the AutoTalk Australia later this week
Join the conversation