Smash repair firms in St George and Sutherland Shire in New South Wales are becoming concerned about insurance companies operating their own repair shops and directing work to businesses prepared to work for lower rates.
Their concerns were backed by a bipartisan parliamentary committee, which found ‘a significant number’ of vehicles were receiving poor quality repairs, ‘potentially increasing safety risks to road user’.
The committee’s mid-year report rejected the need for insurers to be banned from operating their own repair centres, but made 21 recommendations to address problems.
According to repair shop owner Terry Flanagan, there are a lot of dodgy repair jobs happening at his smash repair shop at Penshurst.
“The main losers are the car owners,” he says, who are victims of the disarray in the car repair industry.
He lays the blame at the door of rampant and unregulated insurance companies and a government which refuses to act. “It’s a mess,” he told The Leader.
“The insurance companies want the cheapest deal, so they run their own shops which don’t always do top quality work. Small business is getting bashed big time here by insurance companies and the owners are denied their choice of repairers,” he adds.
Flanagan also notes that the problem could be fixed if the NSW government would implement recommendations from a recent inquiry into the motor vehicle repair industry.
During the six-month inquiry the bipartisan Select Committee on the Motor Vehicle Repair Industry found that poor quality vehicle repair practices were putting motorists at risk and that a major imbalance existed in favour of insurance companies over smash repairers.
A total of 21 recommendations and 12 findings were made, the most important of which included the licensing of motor vehicle assessors to ensure quality, updating the code, providing smash repairers access to the NSW Small Business Commissioner, and ensuring that insurers did not prevent motorists from exercising their choice of repairer if their policy allows it.
Flanagan was joined recently by Labor candidate for Oatley, O’Bray Smith, and the Opposition spokeswoman on fair trading Tania Mihailuk, to call on the NSW government to provide a guarantee that recommendations made by a parliamentary inquiry to improve road safety for motorists would be implemented before the NSW election next year.
“Smash repairers have spoken loud and clear on this issue: they are being forced out of the industry by insurance companies giving preferential treatment to some repairers based on cost rather than quality,” Mihailuk says.
In addition, Smith said that St George motorists “deserved the right to be able to choose a good repairer.”
A spokesman for Fair Trading minister Matthew Mason-Cox said the government was considering all the recommendations, and a “whole-of-government response” would be provided “at the earliest opportunity”.
The inquiry was initiated by Labor with the support of the industry. The committee received 77 submissions and held two public hearings, taking evidence from 24 witnesses.
The government must respond to the recommendations by early January, 2015.
This article originally appeared in The Leader.
Join the conversation