Monday 16 November 2026 Industry news by email, Tuesday and Thursday: sign up
Advertisement
News / Industry News Industry News

Scrap FCAI code of practice: AAA

Max Pichon · 0 comments

The Australian Automobile Association has called on the FCAI and the AADA to reconsider their stance on the question of allowing independent mechanics fair access to vehicle information, as to not do so would be detrimental to consumers.

A new code of practice put out by the Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries relating to access to service and repair information, training and the supply of quality parts has been also backed by the AADA—the body representing motor dealers. The FCAI’s new voluntary code of conduct allows dealers to choose whether or not to make the resources available.

The concern by the AAA is that new car dealerships will be able to access detailed information on vehicle makes and brands which will leave independent mechanics and non-franchised dealers without access to the information, tools and computer programs needed to repair new vehicles.

Advertisement

AAA chief executive Andrew McKellar told AutoTalk that the organisation’s main concern is to ensure that there is an open and competitive marketplace for independent services, and that consumers have a choice in terms of affordability and which repairer to access, when it comes to repairing and servicing their vehicle.

“Our main concern is that as vehicles become more complex and as the commercial pressures and the business model of the OEM’s change then there will be increasing pressure on them to disintermediate others from the supply chain, and that is very clearly a part of the OEM’s global and local strategy,” McKellar told AutoTalk.

“The big risk with this scenario is that the market becomes more concentrated, and if we see repair and service information becoming less accessible, we will see less choice and higher costs for motorists,” he says.

In term of whether there is a discussion of a voluntary vs mandatory code, McKellar dispelled the idea that there is a push for a mandatory code and notes: “We haven’t suggested a mandatory code at all. What has been negotiated is a broader agreement between the FCAI, AADA, the Motor Industry Federation, AAAA, and the AAA, which would be an overarching voluntary agreement.

“It is very different to what the FCAI wants, which is to have their own code of practice, which only applies to their franchised dealership members and would ultimately define what it allows and what it doesn’t allow.”

McKellar argues that the FCAI’s code of practice is full of holes and contains many exemptions, which would commit the FCAI to nothing and describes it as ‘window dressing’.

He called on the FCAI and AADA to commit to a new framework and reinitiate talks with all the groups involved. “It should be based on the principles agreed upon by all the stakeholders and not just on an aggregation of the FCAI’s principles,” McKellar adds.

“We have a meeting with Minister Billson today, and what I will be asking the Minister to do is to bring the OEMs back to the table and open new discussions, to see if the FCAI can fix the problems in their code and ensure that we have a framework that will provide some level of assurance about availability of information going forward.”

McKellar thinks that the missing link in the code is to remove some of the loopholes and adopt a simplified, straightforward definition around what is repair information that is covered by this code of practice.

“There are precedents for it, for example in the United States – if the largest auto market in the world can define their code of practice in a couple of paragraphs without a whole list of exemptions, then I think we can do it as well,” McKellar says.

“Rather than trying to make the code of practice an exercise in legal obfuscation, let’s put in place a more simple, well-motivated, agreement that ensures genuine access to information. Not something that has a whole raft of loopholes and which means the FCAI and the AADA can avoid any type of commitment,” he concludes.

Max Pichon

All articles

Join the conversation