More than half of automotive workers would not recommend the career
The inaugural Australian Automotive Workforce Pulse puts job satisfaction at 74 out of 100 but career advocacy at minus 39, with 57.4% of respondents classified as detractors.
More than half of Australian automotive workers would not recommend the industry as a career, even though most are satisfied with the job they have.
The inaugural Australian Automotive Workforce Pulse puts job satisfaction at 74 out of 100 and career advocacy at minus 39. Of 718 respondents, 57.4% were classified as detractors when asked whether they would recommend automotive as a career, against 18.2% classified as promoters.
Among those reporting positive job satisfaction, 47% were still detractors.
“You can have someone who enjoys the work they do today, but still hesitates to tell another person to build a career in automotive,” Mechanic.com.au chief executive Ryan Davis says.
“Do people feel their skills are properly valued? Can they see where their career is going? Do they believe staying in automotive will give them the future they want?”
The study’s Workforce Health Index, combining job satisfaction, feeling valued, career outlook and career pathway clarity, sits at 68 out of 100. Pathway clarity is the weakest of the four at 58, against job satisfaction on 74 and feeling valued on 73.
The link between the two is stark. Respondents who could not see a clear career path recorded career advocacy of minus 77.6. Those who could see one still recorded minus 5.8, so even workers with a visible path are close to net neutral on recommending the industry.
The shortage is not one problem
Asked in open text what the biggest workforce challenge is, respondents did not converge on a headcount answer. Workforce capability drew 32.9% of coded responses, ahead of labour supply on 17.4%, attracting new entrants on 16.5% and technology and complexity on 16.5%.
Two in three of those who raised technology and complexity did not also raise skills, training or capability, which the report takes as evidence the two pressures move independently.
That cuts across the way the shortage is usually framed. The Motor Trades Association of Australia put the shortfall at 38,000 technicians and trades professionals this month in its call for automotive to be added to skilled migration priorities, a volume argument. The Pulse separates that into distinct pressures, with capability drawing more open-text responses than labour supply. The report cautions the two are not interchangeable and that no single theme captures the whole picture.
On recruitment, 68.2% of current workforce respondents described hiring suitable staff as difficult or very difficult and 40.1% said their workplace was not adequately staffed. Those in workplaces they considered understaffed recorded a Workforce Health Index of 60.6, against 74.2 for those who did not. The report describes that as an association rather than a causal finding.
What holds people
Asked what matters most in choosing an employer, with up to three selections, 53.1% named pay. Work-life balance followed on 39.6%, respect from management on 34.8%, team environment on 32.6% and career progression on 21.4%.
Three of those five are management questions rather than budget questions.
Of current workforce respondents, 57.9% expect to still be in automotive in five years, 22.6% are unsure and 19.5% think they are unlikely to be. The report also flags a possible pressure point six to 10 years into a career, where Workforce Health fell to 60.0 against 69.4 for those with 11 to 20 years, though it cautions the cohort is small.
Wave 1 ran from 27 June to 10 August with 718 accepted Australian responses. It is unweighted and descriptive, respondents were recruited through Mechanic.com.au’s own industry network and could enter a $500 prize draw, and workers under 25 and women were less strongly represented. The methodology was reviewed by Ben Selwyn of Fifth Quadrant in an advisory capacity, which the report notes was not an audit of the dataset. The public edition is available at mechanic.com.au/wave1.
Join the conversation