Wednesday 18 November 2026 Industry news by email, Tuesday and Thursday: sign up
Advertisement
News / Industry News Industry News

Low-speed crash test repair costs analysed

Administrator · 0 comments

 

A crash test program that analysed low-speed collision repair costs of nine of the top selling small vehicles in Australia has shown a huge variation in results.

The test, conducted by NRMA Insurance, aims to encourage consumers to consider repair costs when looking for a new car due to the impact it can have on their insurance premium.

Advertisement

Holden’s Barina came in first place by a significant lead, with the repair cost for a front and rear collision totaling $2574, or 14.3% per cent of its new purchase price. Toyota’s Yaris YRS was the worst performer, with the 10 km/h impact test causing $13,440 in damaged, a whopping 70.8% of the cars $18,990 purchase price.

Nissan’s Micra came in second place, with repair costs of $6056 working out to be 35.6% of its $16,990 new cost.

Ford’s Fiesta was in third with total repair costs of $8850 representing 42.4% of its $20,990 purchase cost.

Robert McDonald, head of research at NRMA Insurance, says the low-speed crash test program was designed to urge car manufacturers to make improvements to bumper bar design to help keep the cost of collision repairs affordable.

“Because of its effective bumper design, Barina did not suffer structural damage and the damage was isolated to the bumper components,” says McDonald.

“It is possible to have effective bumpers on small cars that protect the more expensive parts like headlights and the radiator.”

The Barina hatch and sedan have also been awarded a maximum five-star safety rating from the Australasian New Car Assessment Program (ANCAP).

Steve Curtis, Holden manager vehicle structure and safety integration, says the NRMA Insurance result proved that safety and affordability didn’t have to be mutually exclusive.

“These results reflect the commitment Holden has made to make the Barina not only one of the most affordable small cars on the road, but also one of the safest,” Curtis says.

The low-speed test uses a standardised bumper beam that is 100mm tall with a flexible, energy absorbing cover that replicates a real vehicle bumper system. A backplate which is 200mm tall is fitted to the top surface of the bumper barrier; 25mm behind the front face. This represents the rear structure above the bumper of the vehicle being crashed into.

The tests were run at 10 km/h. The frontal bumper test is conducted with the bumper barrier height set to 455mm from the ground and the rear bumper test to 405mm from the ground. This is to allow for front end dive that occurs during braking.

 

Administrator

All articles

Join the conversation