Franchised new car retailers are very close to seeing reforms that will change the fabric weave of canvas under which thousands of people and businesses operate.
Australia’s franchise sector contributes 9% of the country’s GDP and franchised dealers tip at least $13 billion into that, and the reforms to the Franchising Code of Conduct hope to bring order to chaos.
A 49-page Regulation Impact Statement is seeking specific input on 17 questions derived from seven principles found to be key themes drawn from the 2018 Inquiry into the Franchising Code of Conduct.
The Senate-led inquiry made 71 overall recommendations, including the creation of the Franchising Taskforce to further consider many of the inquiry’s recommendations.
Not all countries have specific franchise laws, but Australia has its own Franchising Code of Conduct which until now has offered little protection for the actual franchisee selling cars to consumers.
In submissions to the inquiry by former franchisees it was revealed that franchisees, not just car dealers, felt they lost control of their operations when new business models, products and pricing strategies were introduced by franchisors.
Many solutions put forward by franchisees to these issues were varied in nature, but the majority wanted franchisors to collaborate with their franchise network and seek input on new business models and pricing strategies before implementing them – often with unquantified results.
Some of the 49 options proposed under the Regulation Impact Statement would result in major changes to the Franchising Code of Conduct if adopted.
The “unbalanced” relationship has affected not just car dealers who, in most instances tend to be clever, well-educated business people who often know what they’re getting themselves into, however, it also tainted what would have been a harmonious, profitable business model between coffee chains, fuel retailers, branded restaurants, pool cleaning, car servicing, automotive battery and tyre retailers, and 1160 other Australian franchise systems and an estimated 79,000 franchise units.
The dynamic franchise industry contributes at least $184 billion to the Australian economy every year, and supports almost half a million employment positions.
And much like car dealers, and the respective automotive associations and representative bodies who also submitted to the Parliamentary Joint Committee in franchising, franchisees revealed widespread discontent with the perceived power imbalance of franchise agreements in favour of franchisors.
Even the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission has recommended the reformed code should prohibit terms forcing franchisees to reimburse franchisors for costs that results from needing to preparing the franchise agreement.
The ACCC suggested this change on the basis that it may deter franchisees from trying to negotiate fairer terms or make amendments to proposed franchise agreements.
Maddocks lawyers has previously referenced recycling and waste giant JJ Richards, whose standard form contracts used to engage small businesses, the ACCC alleged were unfair and therefore void because under section 24 of the Australian Consumer Law they caused “a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and obligations under the contract”, were “not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party advantaged by the term” and “cause financial or other detriment to a consumer if it were relied on”.
“It is important that franchisors ensure their franchise agreements do not confer excessive rights on the franchisor to change aspects of the franchise relationship, business model or operations manuals without a legitimate business requirement,” the firm says.
“Particularly for the drafting of restraint clauses, geographical exclusivity, leasing arrangements, significant changes to marketing fund contributions and post-termination obligations,” it adds.
“Given the importance of having franchise agreements that are clear and enforceable, we think it is likely that the perceived power imbalance will reduce over time,” Maddocks says.
The Franchising Taskforce has released its draft Regulation Impact Statement, highlighting seven principles to be the target of reforms to legislation.
The Australian Automotive Dealer Association says among them, the most important principle it is focused on is the obligation for franchisor car brands to offer returns on significant capital expenditure to franchisees – whom will typically put forward millions in infrastructure investment to take on a franchise.
“Franchised new car dealers are required to invest large sums of capital in facilities and equipment, but all too often they are provided with shorter-term dealer agreements, making it almost impossible to recover one’s investment,” AADA chief executive James Voortamn said recently.
“The RIS has also provided options to limit the ability of franchisors to unilaterally vary agreements; expand the options for dispute resolution and clarify franchisees rights in terms of goodwill,” he adds.
Under Principle 6, the RIS asks: “Under what circumstances should franchisees be allowed a no-fault exit from the franchise system?”
And in trying to define the term “goodwill” in a franchise agreement, the Taskforce is also asking “how might this be done in practice” and “what would be the costs and benefits of this approach”.
Join the conversation